EHCP Appeal Success Rate: What the Tribunal Data Actually Shows
Quick answer Of the SEND Tribunal appeals that reached a decision in 2024/25, 99% were decided...

If your child cannot attend school because of illness, exclusion or any other reason, your council has a legal duty under section 19 of the Education Act 1996 to arrange suitable education for them. It covers mental health as well as physical illness. It applies whether or not your child is on a school roll. And the trigger most parents are never told about: once it is clear a child will be away for 15 days or more, consecutive or added up across the year, the council should be arranging something.
There are 176,361 children in England who miss at least half of school. Almost none of their families have been told that a legal duty exists to educate them anyway, and almost no council volunteers it.
Starting home education? You do not have to work it out from scratch.
Everything in one place, written for the law as it stands in 2026: the legal foundation, ready-to-send deregistration and local-authority letters, printable weekly and term planners, a curriculum guide by subject, and record-keeping logs. The letters and planners, done for you.
Get the System for £49 →This is that duty, in plain English, with the parts other guides get wrong.
Everything you need before you begin home educating in the UK: your legal rights, a deregistration letter template, and a calm first-week plan. Free printable.
No spam. Unsubscribe in one click. We never share your email.
Section 19(1) of the Education Act 1996 makes local authorities responsible for arranging suitable and, normally, full-time education for children of compulsory school age who, because of “exclusion, illness or other reasons”, would not receive suitable education without it.
Those three words, or other reasons, are doing a great deal of work. The duty is not limited to hospital stays. The statutory guidance is explicit that it covers mental health:
“where a child cannot attend school because of a physical or mental health need, and cannot access suitable full-time education, the local authority is responsible for arranging suitable alternative provision.”
Anxiety-based school avoidance, school-related trauma and mental ill health are not excluded from this. They are the point of it.
Be careful here, because this is where a lot of advice online is loose in the other direction. The guidance says plainly:
“There is no absolute legal deadline by which local authorities must start to arrange education for children with additional health needs.”
So anyone telling you the council is automatically in breach on a particular day is overstating it. What the guidance then says is still strong, and it is what you quote back:
You will read almost everywhere that the council must provide “a minimum of five hours a week”. Council pages say it. Parenting sites say it. Charities repeat it.
That figure does not appear anywhere in the current statutory guidance. We searched the December 2023 document in full. It is not in there. It comes from earlier guidance that has since been replaced.
What the current guidance actually says is more useful to you, not less:
So if you are offered a few hours a week, the question is not “is this five hours”. It is “why is this not full-time, and how is part-time in my child’s best interests?” That is a much harder question for a council to answer.
This one is missed almost universally, and it matters enormously if you have deregistered or are thinking about it. The guidance says the duty to arrange suitable full-time education:
“applies whether the child is on the roll of a school or not and whatever type of school they attend.”
Read that before you deregister in desperation. Choosing elective home education does transfer responsibility for your child’s education to you, and councils will often treat a deregistration as closing the matter. But withdrawing your child is a decision you should take because you want to home educate, not because you were told there was no alternative. If your child cannot attend and you have not chosen home education, ask about section 19 first.
A common experience: the council asks for medical evidence, the GP will not write what is asked for, and months pass. The guidance limits this in two ways:
Absence of a letter is not permission to do nothing.
Go through the council’s formal complaints procedure first, in writing, and let it run its course. If that does not resolve it, you can complain to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, which is free.
The Ombudsman takes this duty seriously and publishes its decisions. It has repeatedly found fault where councils failed to consider section 19 at all, and has ordered apologies, policy changes and financial remedies. In one 2024 decision the council was told to pay £3,400 to recognise the injustice of a child not receiving sufficient education. You can read the published alternative provision decisions yourself, and finding one against your own council is often persuasive.
The legal test the Ombudsman applies is whether there is suitable education available that is “reasonably practicable” for the child to access. A school place that exists on paper but that your child genuinely cannot attend may not meet that test.
Severe absence, meaning a child missing 50% or more of sessions, has risen about 44% since 2021/22 even while overall absence improved. It is not rare and you are not an outlier.
Section 19 of the Education Act 1996 requires a local authority in England to arrange suitable, normally full-time, education for a child of compulsory school age who because of exclusion, illness or other reasons would not otherwise receive suitable education.
Yes. The statutory guidance states that where a child cannot attend school because of a physical or mental health need and cannot access suitable full-time education, the local authority is responsible for arranging suitable alternative provision.
There is no absolute legal deadline. The statutory guidance says that as soon as it is clear a child will be away for 15 days or more, consecutive or cumulative across a school year, the council should arrange provision, and that provision should begin at the latest by the sixth day of absence. Where absence is planned, arrangements should allow provision to start from day one.
No, and that figure is not in the current guidance. The December 2023 statutory guidance contains no minimum weekly hours. It requires suitable full-time education, says the law does not define full-time, and says provision should where possible be equivalent to what the child would receive in a mainstream school. Part-time is only appropriate where full-time would not be in the child’s best interests.
The guidance says the duty applies whether or not the child is on the roll of a school. If you have chosen elective home education you have taken on responsibility for providing that education yourself, so speak to your local SENDIASS about how the duty applies to your particular situation before assuming either way.
Use the council’s formal complaints procedure in writing first. If that fails, you can complain free of charge to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman, which has repeatedly found councils at fault over this duty and has ordered apologies, policy changes and financial remedies.
This is information, not legal advice
Darling Mellow is a parenting website. We are not solicitors, we are not regulated to give legal advice, and nothing here is advice about your particular child or situation. We write about the law in England, we date everything and we link our sources so you can check them. Deadlines and duties change, and only you know your full circumstances, so please take proper advice before making a decision that matters.
Where to get free or regulated advice
If you are in Wales, Scotland or Northern Ireland, the law and the services differ and you should use your own nation’s guidance.
Real talk from real UK mums. Ask questions, share advice, find local groups near you.
Join the Community →Ready to make a start, the calm way?
Everything in one place, written for the law as it stands in 2026: the legal foundation, ready-to-send deregistration and local-authority letters, printable weekly and term planners, a curriculum guide by subject, and record-keeping logs. The letters and planners, done for you.
Get the System for £49 →Found this helpful? Take the next step ↓
Your legal rights, a deregistration letter template, and a calm first-week plan.
Download it free →Everything to start home educating in the UK — the legal startup kit, deregistration and LA letters, curriculum options and a weekly planner, in one system.
Get it - £49 →Pop in your email and we will send the starter checklist straight away: the legal basics, how to deregister, and a calm first week. Plus one short email a week with new guides, free tools, and what is changing in the law. No spam, ever.
Free forever · Unsubscribe in one click · We never share your email
Everything you need before you begin home educating in the UK: your legal rights, a deregistration letter template, and a calm first-week plan. Free printable.
Join 2,400+ UK mums on The Mellow Post. Unsubscribe any time.